It is hard to know what should be closed and what shouldn't and we are still in the process of finding that out. There have been a couple of closes that I don't think that are that obvious so here it goes.
If I convert my US Dollars to Bitcoins, will its value likely depreciate?
Well, this has a clear answer: "it depends on whether the price goes up or down". What is exactly speculative about this?
This is probably the most asked question ever in the bitcointalk forums and I think it can be answered "timelessly" - this one is really similar. Besides, the too localized argument fits half of the questions asked here (but that would be whole other topic...)
There are a few others, but these caught my attention. Anyway, it's just to say that sometimes a question may seem really vague and ambiguous, but it can have a good answer.
So, are we being too harsh on close votes or should we keep a really strict policy? (this was just to avoid closed as not a real question ;))