Skip to main content
replaced http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/ with https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Arguments in favor of removing it:

  • As a tag, it's pretty vague. It's sort of like tagging your questions with 'not-bitcoin'.
  • If it's supposed to go on all non-bitcoin questions, then that's not being done right now.

Argument against: Some questions, like this onethis one are actually about alternative blockchains in general. In that context, it doesn't really make sense to remove the tag.

My opinion: Remove the tag on questions that have a more specific tag. However, when someone wants to ask about bitcoin alternatives in general, leave the 'alternatives' tag.

For example: If I'm asking about how Litecoin's hashing algorithm works, then that shouldn't be tagged alternatives. However, if I'm asking for an overview of different proof-of-work schemes used by alternate blockchains, then that ought to be tagged alternatives or alternative-blockchains

Arguments in favor of removing it:

  • As a tag, it's pretty vague. It's sort of like tagging your questions with 'not-bitcoin'.
  • If it's supposed to go on all non-bitcoin questions, then that's not being done right now.

Argument against: Some questions, like this one are actually about alternative blockchains in general. In that context, it doesn't really make sense to remove the tag.

My opinion: Remove the tag on questions that have a more specific tag. However, when someone wants to ask about bitcoin alternatives in general, leave the 'alternatives' tag.

For example: If I'm asking about how Litecoin's hashing algorithm works, then that shouldn't be tagged alternatives. However, if I'm asking for an overview of different proof-of-work schemes used by alternate blockchains, then that ought to be tagged alternatives or alternative-blockchains

Arguments in favor of removing it:

  • As a tag, it's pretty vague. It's sort of like tagging your questions with 'not-bitcoin'.
  • If it's supposed to go on all non-bitcoin questions, then that's not being done right now.

Argument against: Some questions, like this one are actually about alternative blockchains in general. In that context, it doesn't really make sense to remove the tag.

My opinion: Remove the tag on questions that have a more specific tag. However, when someone wants to ask about bitcoin alternatives in general, leave the 'alternatives' tag.

For example: If I'm asking about how Litecoin's hashing algorithm works, then that shouldn't be tagged alternatives. However, if I'm asking for an overview of different proof-of-work schemes used by alternate blockchains, then that ought to be tagged alternatives or alternative-blockchains

Source Link
Nick ODell
  • 29.5k
  • 13
  • 16

Arguments in favor of removing it:

  • As a tag, it's pretty vague. It's sort of like tagging your questions with 'not-bitcoin'.
  • If it's supposed to go on all non-bitcoin questions, then that's not being done right now.

Argument against: Some questions, like this one are actually about alternative blockchains in general. In that context, it doesn't really make sense to remove the tag.

My opinion: Remove the tag on questions that have a more specific tag. However, when someone wants to ask about bitcoin alternatives in general, leave the 'alternatives' tag.

For example: If I'm asking about how Litecoin's hashing algorithm works, then that shouldn't be tagged alternatives. However, if I'm asking for an overview of different proof-of-work schemes used by alternate blockchains, then that ought to be tagged alternatives or alternative-blockchains